Use These 5 Tips to Build a Compelling ESG Story in Today’s Evolving D&O Market

ESG ratings don’t always tell the whole story, which is why companies should develop a clear and compelling ESG story for D&O underwriters.
Key Takeaways
-
ESG is increasingly becoming a significant risk-selection component among underwriters for Directors and Officers (D&O) Liability Insurance.
-
D&O insurers mostly rely on ESG ratings from outside agencies that claim to offer stakeholders a clear picture of how a company is managing ESG risks.
-
Having a compelling ESG story ready to share with D&O underwriters is critical in accurately reflecting the company’s values and commitments.
As business demands and expectations evolve, corporate boards and leaders are increasingly being held accountable for their organization’s environmental, social and governance (ESG) strategy and performance. It is therefore unsurprising that ESG is increasingly becoming a significant risk-selection component among underwriters for Directors and Officers Liability Insurance (D&O).
Proper oversight of ESG materiality factors is imperative. Organizations that do not actively manage or address this topic open themselves up to potential litigation risk or regulatory investigations and actions.
D&O insurers mostly rely on ESG ratings from outside agencies that claim to offer stakeholders a clear picture of how a company is managing ESG risks. However, with a proliferation of ESG ratings providers and no standardized methodologies, there is now greater recognition that ratings might not tell the whole story. This reality heightens the need for companies to proactively and thoroughly disclose their ESG oversight journey with D&O underwriters at renewal.
Why ESG Has Gained Underwriting Prominence
Underwriters face exposure to litigation on a broad spectrum of ESG-related matters, such as climate change mitigation and inclusion and diversity policies. “Greenwashing,” the practice of exaggerating claims about ESG progress and attributes, is also becoming a growing D&O litigation concern.1 Stakeholders, including investors, employees and consumers, increasingly expect companies to not only make commitments to ESG topics, but also hold them accountable when commitments are not met.
Similarly, many companies must make a number of ESG-related disclosures to comply with relevant regulations. To aid in these complex calculations of risk, ESG ratings firms evaluate companies’ plans, their adherence to those plans and how they stack up against their peers.
Because there is a solid connection between good governance (the G in ESG) and fewer, less severe losses in D&O, companies benefit from highly interested and engaged D&O insurers that offer competitive options in exchange for competent governance. Even further, incorporating a company’s environmental and social impact will help improve ratings and D&O policy renewal discussions, in addition to helping a company avoid red flags.
Ratings Don’t Tell the Whole Story
ESG ratings firms are increasingly scrambling to provide accurate, timely and relevant information as demand for ESG information continues to grow. To keep pace with the market, different ratings agencies are developing their own criteria to evaluate how well a company is mitigating ESG risks. Meanwhile, no industry-wide standards have been developed to help insurers and other stakeholders interpret the different ratings. Even if some agencies are using similar criteria, how they weigh each one can produce drastically different results, causing some to call into question the reliability of the assessments.2
Another challenge with ESG ratings is the elevated expectations that come with high ratings. Some companies in Europe are seeing that higher-rated companies face increased shareholder activism or threats of litigation. This is true either when targets are not met or when financial performance suffers. Investors are likely to ask if the company overcommitted or perhaps focused too much on non-financial issues, leading to poor performance.
How to Share a Compelling and Honest ESG Story
So how can companies overcome the inconsistencies with ESG ratings? The key is in the story behind the ratings. An outside party rating a company’s ESG efforts is only getting a snapshot of the company at a certain point in time. The rating may not necessarily incorporate where the company started on its ESG journey or the progress it has made along the way. A company can receive a poor rating that may not reflect the steps it took to reach its ESG goals or recognize the significant progress that has been made since the inception of ESG initiatives.
When talking about a company’s ESG story, it’s important to keep in mind the broad audience that is listening, including, among others, employees, prospective employees, investors, advisors, suppliers, competitors and insurance underwriters. Emphasizing different elements for each intended audience will help drive engagement with the company’s ESG story and strike an appropriate balance among competing interests. However, the company should have a strong overall narrative that’s backed by data and not only resonates with the various stakeholders, but also accurately reflects the company’s values and commitments.
The biggest mistake a company can make in its ESG storytelling is overcommitting to goals they can’t reach or have no intention of reaching.
Five Tips for a Successful ESG Story
Here are five helpful tips to always keep in mind:
1. Understand the material risk factors that are relevant to your company, industry and size and decide which frameworks make sense to disclose.
The ESG risk factors you report should consider what matters to your investors and other priority stakeholders. They also must align with your ESG strategy, corporate initiatives and what others in your industry are reporting.3
2. Highlight board oversight of your ESG strategy, so that all involved can have confidence in strong governance practices.
Standardized policies, procedures, controls and governance are crucial for demonstrating your firm’s ESG management efficiency.
3. Design your reporting architecture and tools to ensure accuracy and effectiveness.
By applying a standardized approach to sourcing your ESG data and aligning it to existing frameworks, you can improve the quality of your ESG reporting.
4. Calibrate your story by striking an appropriate balance of achievable goals to satisfy multiple stakeholders.
While many companies would love to aim for aggressive carbon reduction targets, it’s important to keep in mind the risk of overreaching. Even if successful, any shortcomings will be amplified by both ratings agencies and other stakeholders.
5. Develop a way to tell a consistent, coherent and authentic story.
Firms that tell a clear and compelling story can establish themselves as leaders in the market. Critical stakeholders, such as investors and underwriters,4 will more favorably view how you are navigating your ESG journey.
General Disclaimer
The information contained herein and the statements expressed are of a general nature and are not intended to address the circumstances of any particular individual or entity. Although we endeavor to provide accurate and timely information and use sources we consider reliable, there can be no guarantee that such information is accurate as of the date it is received or that it will continue to be accurate in the future. No one should act on such information without appropriate professional advice after a thorough examination of the particular situation.
Terms of Use
The contents herein may not be reproduced, reused, reprinted or redistributed without the expressed written consent of Aon, unless otherwise authorized by Aon. To use information contained herein, please write to our team.
Aon's Better Being Podcast
Our Better Being podcast series, hosted by Aon Chief Wellbeing Officer Rachel Fellowes, explores wellbeing strategies and resilience. This season we cover human sustainability, kindness in the workplace, how to measure wellbeing, managing grief and more.
Aon Insights Series Asia
Expert Views on Today's Risk Capital and Human Capital Issues
Aon Insights Series Pacific
Expert Views on Today's Risk Capital and Human Capital Issues
Aon Insights Series UK
Expert Views on Today's Risk Capital and Human Capital Issues
Construction and Infrastructure
The construction industry is under pressure from interconnected risks and notable macroeconomic developments. Learn how your organization can benefit from construction insurance and risk management.
Cyber Labs
Stay in the loop on today's most pressing cyber security matters.
Cyber Resilience
Our Cyber Resilience collection gives you access to Aon’s latest insights on the evolving landscape of cyber threats and risk mitigation measures. Reach out to our experts to discuss how to make the right decisions to strengthen your organization’s cyber resilience.
Employee Wellbeing
Our Employee Wellbeing collection gives you access to the latest insights from Aon's human capital team. You can also reach out to the team at any time for assistance with your employee wellbeing needs.
Environmental, Social and Governance Insights
Explore Aon's latest environmental social and governance (ESG) insights.
Q4 2023 Global Insurance Market Insights
Our Global Insurance Market Insights highlight insurance market trends across pricing, capacity, underwriting, limits, deductibles and coverages.
Regional Results
How do the top risks on business leaders’ minds differ by region and how can these risks be mitigated? Explore the regional results to learn more.
Human Capital Analytics
Our Human Capital Analytics collection gives you access to the latest insights from Aon's human capital team. Contact us to learn how Aon’s analytics capabilities helps organizations make better workforce decisions.
Insights for HR
Explore our hand-picked insights for human resources professionals.
Workforce
Our Workforce Collection provides access to the latest insights from Aon’s Human Capital team on topics ranging from health and benefits, retirement and talent practices. You can reach out to our team at any time to learn how we can help address emerging workforce challenges.
Mergers and Acquisitions
Our Mergers and Acquisitions (M&A) collection gives you access to the latest insights from Aon's thought leaders to help dealmakers make better decisions. Explore our latest insights and reach out to the team at any time for assistance with transaction challenges and opportunities.
Navigating Volatility
How do businesses navigate their way through new forms of volatility and make decisions that protect and grow their organizations?
Parametric Insurance
Our Parametric Insurance Collection provides ways your organization can benefit from this simple, straightforward and fast-paying risk transfer solution. Reach out to learn how we can help you make better decisions to manage your catastrophe exposures and near-term volatility.
Pay Transparency and Equity
Our Pay Transparency and Equity collection gives you access to the latest insights from Aon's human capital team on topics ranging from pay equity to diversity, equity and inclusion. Contact us to learn how we can help your organization address these issues.
Property Risk Management
Forecasters are predicting an extremely active 2024 Atlantic hurricane season. Take measures to build resilience to mitigate risk for hurricane-prone properties.
Technology
Our Technology Collection provides access to the latest insights from Aon's thought leaders on navigating the evolving risks and opportunities of technology. Reach out to the team to learn how we can help you use technology to make better decisions for the future.
Top 10 Global Risks
Trade, technology, weather and workforce stability are the central forces in today’s risk landscape.
Trade
Our Trade Collection gives you access to the latest insights from Aon's thought leaders on navigating the evolving risks and opportunities for international business. Reach out to our team to understand how to make better decisions around macro trends and why they matter to businesses.
Weather
With a changing climate, organizations in all sectors will need to protect their people and physical assets, reduce their carbon footprint, and invest in new solutions to thrive. Our Weather Collection provides you with critical insights to be prepared.
Workforce Resilience
Our Workforce Resilience collection gives you access to the latest insights from Aon's Human Capital team. You can reach out to the team at any time for questions about how we can assess gaps and help build a more resilience workforce.
More Like This
-
Article 7 mins
Why Organizations Need a Robust Directors and Officers Risk Program
A variety of growing risks, including shareholder derivative actions, an evolving regulatory environment and bankruptcy filings, are why public and private organizations must protect their corporate directors and officers.
-
Article 15 mins
Navigating Cyber Risks in EMEA: Key Insights for 2025
Organizations in EMEA face unprecedented challenges as cyber threats become more sophisticated. In the face of emerging AI, evolving regulations and geopolitical tensions, businesses should strengthen their resilience to better navigate the complexities of the digital age.
-
Article 6 mins
Outsourced Chief Investment Officer: The Key to Navigating Volatility
In a volatile climate, institutional investors are turning to outsourced chief investment officers to conquer administrative, regulatory and market challenges.
-
Article 6 mins
Understanding the Financial Landscape of Wind Energy
Investment in both onshore and offshore wind power is not only fundamental to our energy security strategy but also delivering wider social and economic benefits through the creation of jobs and investments in local communities around the world.
-
Article 8 mins
The CFO Roadmap: Expanding Success Beyond Financial Metrics
In today's intricate business environment, growth is expanding to include more than financial success. By understanding how to fund, shape and secure growth, organizations can build resilience and drive long-term value.
-
Article 8 mins
Cyber and E&O Market Conditions Remain Favorable Amid Emerging Global Risks
Despite higher claims frequency, the cyber and tech E&O markets remain in a favorable pricing and well-capitalized environment. However, buyers must remain vigilant and manage a variety of current and emerging cyber risks and threat actor attack methods.
-
Article 4 mins
5 Steps for Successful Carbon Accounting Verification
Organizations can demonstrate their commitment to global sustainability and a low-carbon future by addressing verification challenges and adopting best practices.
-
Article 15 mins
Management Liability Insurance Market in 2025: Stability Amid Evolving Risks
Market stability prevails in management liability lines as insurers continue to seek market share. However, expanding technologies, increased litigation and macroeconomic factors are causing growing uncertainty and underwriting concerns.
-
Article 7 mins
A Comprehensive Approach to Financial Wellbeing
There is an opportunity to develop a strategy around financial education in the workplace. Globally, our latest data finds 11 percent of employees receive financial education from their employer, but 37 percent expect it. How can employers bridge this gap?
-
Article 12 mins
UK Insurance Market Outlook
The UK insurance market has seen increased competition and softening conditions. Insurers have capitalized on strong financials and capacity, benefiting buyers. Yet, challenges in specific areas have required strategic engagement and robust risk management for optimal outcomes.
-
Article 12 mins
Why Pay Equity Should Be Every Food, Agribusiness and Beverage Leader’s Priority
With growing global regulations and rising stakeholder and talent expectations, pay equity has shifted from a mere HR initiative to a top C-suite priority that goes beyond compliance.
-
Article 7 mins
How Technology is Transforming Open Enrollment in the U.S.
A well-structured open enrollment process is one that leverages innovative technology, encourages cost-effective use of healthcare resources and reduces unnecessary spending — benefiting both employees and employers.
-
Article 19 mins
3 Strategies to Promote an Inclusive Environment and Bridge the Gender Gap
While there have been significant strides toward a more inclusive workforce, the gender pay gap persists. Discover how organizations can continue to make progress with interconnected policies and comprehensive programs that support an inclusive environment at every career and life stage.
-
Article 15 mins
2025 Life Sciences Outlook: Building Preparedness to Mitigate Risks and Capture Human Capital Opportunities
After a period of significant volatility, a more optimistic outlook is on the horizon for the life sciences industry in 2025. With the right level of preparedness, firms can take full advantage of the potential opportunities the new year will bring.
-
Article 6 mins
Decarbonizing Construction for a Low-Emission Future
Decarbonizing construction demands new materials and approaches, with a focus on managing risk and securing capital. By aligning sustainability with business strategy and risk management, the industry can meet net-zero targets.
-
Article 2 mins
Risk Analyzer Suite
Aon’s Risk Analyzer Suite delivers quantitative analytics, improved risk insights and supports operational efficiency.
-
Article 8 mins
Employer Strategies for Cancer Prevention and Treatment
Nearly 20 million people get cancer each year,<sup>1</sup> and the impact is far-reaching — from those diagnosed to their loved ones and colleagues. When developing a meaningful cancer prevention strategy, employers must show empathy and compassion while managing rising costs.
-
Alert 14 mins
L.A. Wildfires Highlight Urgent Need for Employee Support and Business Resilience
In the face of the L.A. wildfires, impacted businesses’ top priority is their people. A three-phased approach can help build business resilience and mitigate the effects of future events.
-
Article 23 mins
The AI Data Center Boom: Strategies for Sustainable Growth and Risk Management
Rapid growth in data center construction, spurred by AI advancements and cloud demand, creates interconnected risks for developers. However, with effective risk management solutions, navigating this dynamic market while prioritizing sustainability is possible.
-
Article 8 mins
Mitigating Volatility and Maximizing Profits: A Guide to Risk Capital in the Food, Agribusiness and Beverage Industry
In an industry with tight operating margins, FAB organizations face significant challenges in managing spend and protecting their financial health — requiring industry leaders to adopt a sophisticated approach to risk capital optimization.
-
Article 15 mins
5 Top Trends for Risk Capital in 2025
The risk capital landscape is poised for change, driven by emerging trends reshaping market dynamics. With a buyer-friendly market currently prevailing across most lines, opportunities abound for strategic investment and risk management.
-
Article 9 mins
3 Strategies to Help Avoid Workers Compensation Claims Litigation
When a workers compensation claim goes to litigation, expenses rise dramatically — a burden that is often shouldered by the business. To mitigate attorney-related costs, organizations should re-think their approach to engaging injured workers and use artificial intelligence to enhance outcomes.
-
Article 35 mins
5 Human Resources Trends to Watch in 2025
Human resources is increasingly involved in all areas of a company’s strategy. As the workforce changes, HR leaders should identify and leverage these five important and evolving trends.
-
Article 6 mins
The Long-Term Care Conundrum in the United States
Long-term care is expensive, and costs are rising due to shortages. With the population aging at the fastest rate in a century, finding solutions to pay for care is an urgent priority. How can employers support this growing population?
-
Article 7 mins
Improving Benefit Communication for a Multi-Generational U.S. Workforce
With a multi-generational and diverse workforce, it is important for employers to develop benefit communications and engagement strategies to help employees understand their unique benefit options. Here are five useful tips to consider.
-
Article 13 mins
Medical Rate Trends and Mitigation Strategies Across the Globe
Rising medical costs are a global phenomenon. Aon’s 2025 Global Medical Trend Rate Survey found that costs are projected to rise 10 percent in 2025.
-
Article 7 mins
Key Trends in U.S. Benefits for 2025 and Beyond
As healthcare costs continue to rise, employers are trying to balance the need to take care of their workers with the need to keep costs under control. Aon’s 2025 U.S. Health Survey provides insights into the choices employers are making, and their potential effects on costs.
-
Article 9 mins
Pension Reform: Navigating the Future of Retirement
Pension reforms in Europe are reshaping retirement planning, demanding more oversight from employers and new strategies for employees’ financial wellbeing.
-
Article 6 mins
Managing Non-Financial Risks to Build Organizational Resilience in the Financial Institutions Industry
Non-financial risks are often difficult to predict and quantify, yet present a real threat to financial institutions. In this volatile environment, risk management is playing a greater role in creating business resilience and identifying where capital should be deployed.
-
Article 9 mins
Ensuring Operational Stability Post-Spin-Off: A Conversation with Daniel Halter from Sandoz
Daniel Halter, Director Global Insurance at Sandoz, discusses how smart risk and insurance management supported the Sandoz core mission to provide affordable, off-patent medicines to patients who need them most with Ana Serdarevic, Head of Aon’s Transaction Advisory Services for DACH.
-
Article 7 mins
How to Navigate AI-Driven Cyber Risks
Business leaders are aware of AI-driven cyber risks and their implications. But understanding changing risk profiles to make better decisions around the management of new exposures is the key to cyber resilience.
-
Article 9 mins
U.S. Rail Sectors Work to Mitigate Capacity and Pricing Risk Issues
U.S. freight and commuter rail industries are facing excess liability and property issues for different reasons. These railroads are critical to infrastructure and vital to the economy, yet finding effective solutions remains complex.
-
Article 11 mins
D&O Risks and Considerations for Businesses Planning an IPO
As private companies prepare for an IPO, they face increased risks that require directors and key leaders to adopt essential risk management strategies to ensure a smooth transition.
-
Article 10 mins
How Public Entities and Businesses Can Use Parametric for Emergency Funding
As climate change intensifies the frequency and severity of extreme weather events, public entities and businesses need more flexible funding solutions. Parametric stands out as an adaptable resource capable of swiftly responding to potential disasters.
-
Article 17 mins
How Insurance Helps Unlock Capital for Hydrogen Projects Amid Financing Pressures
Funding challenges due to macroeconomic factors have prevented several green and blue hydrogen projects from getting off the ground. Organizations facing hurdles in accessing capital can work with risk and insurance experts to expedite projects and help make the promise of hydrogen a reality.
-
Article 11 mins
Strengthening Human Capital Strategies to Attract Talent in the Food, Agribusiness and Beverage Industry
Learn how strong human capital strategies can help recruit, retain and motivate vital talent in a competitive and evolving job market.
-
Article 7 mins
Trends U.S. Corporate Boards Should Prepare for in 2025
As corporate boards meet to discuss strategy, including any changes to executive compensation, there are key trends to consider for the year ahead.
-
Article 6 mins
Leading the Biofuels Transition: Risk Strategies to Cut Through Complexity
Companies aiming to be a net-zero company may face many challenges during the biofuels transition. Read more on risk strategies to cut through complexity.
-
Article 6 mins
DC Pension Schemes: Improving Investment Returns
With DC schemes growing across Europe, many organizations are realizing the importance of ensuring strong performance from their investments. Here’s how asset owners and managers can optimize DC outcomes through the right investment strategy.
-
Article 9 mins
Developing a Paid Leave Strategy That Supports Workers and Their Families
With no federal paid leave law in the U.S., employers have limited guidance in designing equitable and comprehensive paid leave programs to support their workforce. Looking beyond compliance to focus on strategy and values will help create fair and well-designed policies.
-
Article 8 mins
Unlock the Potential of Alternative Risk Transfer Solutions
Risk managers are increasingly looking to Alternative Risk Transfer Solutions for potential enhancements in managing risk.
-
Article 8 mins
2025 Salary Increase Planning Tips
Amid economic uncertainty, companies are taking a careful approach to hiring and salary planning — one that includes focused hiring strategies, revising salary budgets and implementing measures that respond to the current economic environment.
-
Alert 7 mins
Client Alert: Responding to Heightened Risk in the Middle East
The current operating environment in the Middle East is increasingly complex and multifaceted, characterized by ongoing conflicts in Gaza, Israel, Lebanon and neighboring states, alongside significant changes in the business and insurance environment.
-
Article 8 mins
Florida Hurricanes Not Expected to Adversely Affect Property Market
Hurricanes Helene and Milton insured loss estimates are expected to fall between $34 billion and $54 billion. Healthy, well-capitalized insurance and reinsurance markets are positioned to absorb those losses.
-
Article